Pokémon Remake Discussion (Read First Post!) (2024)

Joshawott said:

Did I only mention FRLG? Nope I didn't =3. Earlier this year there was a (false) rumour of a 3DS remake of Pokémon XD which has sparked interested in those games. Also, who says only main series games can be remade? You never know with Pokémon.

Also in regards to DP, discussion of Generation IV and V remakes isn't allowed simply because the idea of them at this point is silly.

Click to expand...

I would like for there to be a remake of Xd/colosseum or just a new pokemon game like that on the Wii, probably not, but on a ps3 or Xbox.

Shiny Celebi said:

I doubt a Pokemon remake would be on a non Nintendo console. Pokemon has always been played on a Nintendo device, and probably always will be.

Click to expand...

I would play it more if it was, I don't play my wii that much. It bores me.

TerranceReid said:

GAMEFREAK would probably stop making remakes unless it's something big like a 100th anniversary when they'll probably remake Red and Blue/Green

Click to expand...

100th anniversary? I can see 30th, maybe 50th at the most, but 100th? Not a single member of Nintendo/ Game Freak that is working now will be working then. I can hardly see an game/ anime/ manga/ whatever-else franchise continuing for a hundred years. I think it impossible, but I could be wrong, you never know with Pokemon.

Anyways, back to the point, I will buy a 3DS if RSE remakes comeout on the 3DS. RSE were arguably my favorite games. I really don't have much problems with it.
Bump up the graphics, have proper rivals, give Wally a proper storyline, update Pokedex to Pre-evos/ evos, more/ larger secret bases with more items and you're done. I hope they won't include any other regions, it would take up to much space on the pak and they'd have to dumb everything down.
I personally can't wait!!

Aquamarine Phoenix said:

Bump up the graphics, have proper rivals, give Wally a proper storyline, update Pokedex to Pre-evos/ evos, more/ larger secret bases with more items and you're done. I hope they won't include any other regions, it would take up to much space on the pak and they'd have to dumb everything down.
I personally can't wait!!

Click to expand...

You pretty much got it done there, Hoenn DESERVES to be on the 3DS, especially considering how nature based it is.

With everyone talking about how it'll be BW graphics, that wouldn't be too bad, but imo they might as well just market it as a DS game then. They started on BW almost instantly after DP were finished and that was some time before they would know about the 3DS being ready/released so most likely they were too far into development then. These remakes would have had to have been started a fair amount of time after that and by then they probably had time to switch over if they had already started(since they were among the first to receive a 3DS development kit); they also already have a 'base'(seeing as they are remakes and not entirely new games).

Anyways, my point is that they could do far better and would benefit more, I wouldn't mind the extra wait. They can do whatever they want, I just can only hope that they release on the 3DS.

Without the Battle Frontier and Scott...it's not worth considering buying. But judging by the way the remakes of G/S/C went, we can rest assured.
Also, we need to have the Weather trio confrontation be like it was in Emerald, which plays directly to the legend made (Rayquaza putting them both back to sleep).
In light of a remake, and not a sequel (if sequel applies, then Wally as Champion) Steven needs to be the Champion, not Wallace. They need to make Steven less of a push-over too. Maybe with Gen IV or V Pokes (Metagross, Skarmory, Aggron, Excadrill, Bastiodon, Empoleon)? Make Wallace a Contest-master, like they made Jasmine, your mother, and Fantina in DP. Or make him a post-game boss, like Steven was. And leave Juan as the Gym Leader in Sootopolis no matter what.

The triple battles make a lot of sense during the Team battle on Mt. Chimney (was your friendly Team leader not triple battling three grunts anyway in the originals?). The Magma/Aqua confrontations beg for Triple/Rotation battles.

And no Musicals. Most pointless things ever. I tried it once, and forgot the point. But then realized I had forgotten it because there wasn't one. At least Contests or Pokethalons have a goal in mind.

And lastly, besides implementing the obvious seasons and weather and night/day, make the rivals more rival-like and less...shallow. Please?

sonic10158 said:

It should be on the 3DS, it's time the upgraded to the new handheld.

Click to expand...

FINALLY SOMEONE AGRRE"S WITH ME!!!! They moved {Pokemon to the 3DS alreadu with Rumble.. makes absolutly no sense for Grey and TR/MS (Terra Ruby/Maris Saphire (Land and Sea in Latin)) to be on the DS... and B/W tales place several years after Pt